New York Giants’ All-Time Impact Players Over the Past 25 Years Since 2000

By Jim Tomlin

@jdtomlin68

May 3, 2025 04:57pm

At the dawn of this millennium, the New York Giants emerged as one of the most formidable franchises in the NFL, making it to the Super Bowl three times and claiming two championships within 12 years, from 2000 to 2011. Unfortunately, the latter part of this quarter-century has yielded fewer successes, with the Giants only reaching the playoffs twice since their victory in Super Bowl 46.

deereplanet.com wanted customers atOntario betting sites To determine the standout Giants players since the year 2000, we compiled a roster similar to an NFL starting lineup. This includes one quarterback, two wide receivers, etc., and is based on Approximate Value (AV) statistics sourced from pro-football-reference.

Stay updated with the latest sports insights, including news, tips, picks, and special promotions featuring competitive betting odds across a wide range of sports, all on a dual-platform sportsbook and casino.

Sign Up

Participants must be at least 19 years old. Terms and conditions apply, and responsible gaming practices are encouraged.

Participants must be at least 19 years old. Terms and conditions apply, and responsible gaming practices are encouraged.

Giants’ Quarter-Century Offense

Ranked second in franchise history for Approximate Value, Eli Manning stands out in the data as a legendary player. His career AV from 2004 to 2019 is 169, just behind the Hall of Fame linebacker Lawrence Taylor. Pro Football Reference Our analysis provides a modern perspective on betting opportunities for the team.New York Giants betting guide Besides Eli Manning, the only other offensive player from the last 25 years who achieved an AV above 100 for the Giants is the celebrated running back Tiki Barber. He amassed a career AV of 122 from 1997 to 2006, ranking fifth in franchise history, although on our list it stands at 105 due to our focus on data from 2000 onwards. Barber is the Giants' all-time leading rusher, with 10,449 yards, and his 55 rushing touchdowns place him second behind Brandon Jacobs.

Adjust your betting preferences, enjoy seamless wallet integration for all products, and experience hassle-free deposits.

For terms and conditions, visit BetMGM.com. Must be 19+. Ontario Only . New Customer Promotions. All offers require meeting specific qualification and eligibility criteria. Bonuses are issued as non-cashable bet credits. All bet credits expire within 7 days of issuance. Gamble Responsibly. If you have any questions or concerns regarding your gambling or someone close to you, please reach out to ConnexOntario at 1-866-531-2600 for free advice .

Sign Up

The challenges facing the Giants are evident, especially to those who follow the NFL and place bets. Last season, they finished with a record of 3-14, marking their lowest winning percentage (.176) since the dismal 1974 season when they managed only two wins.

The challenges facing the Giants are evident, especially to those who follow the NFL and place bets. Last season, they finished with a record of 3-14, marking their lowest winning percentage (.176) since the dismal 1974 season when they managed only two wins.

Giants’ Quarter-Century Defense

In recent years, the Giants have seen a decline in star talent compared to the early 2000s, which is highlighted by the fact that only one current player made it onto this list. That player is defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence (shown here), who has earned Pro Bowl selections in each of the past three seasons. With an AV of 55 over six seasons, he leads all recent players in performance metrics for the Giants.sports betting apps in Ontario The team's recent performance has been lacking, prompting hopes that they might discover the next Michael Strahan during this month's NFL Draft. Strahan holds the highest defensive AV for the Giants over the last quarter-century at 87, based solely on metrics from 2000 onward. Throughout his career from 1993 to 2007, he accumulated a career AV of 161 and was selected as a first-team All-Pro by the Associated Press four times before his induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Looking ahead to the 2025-26 NFL season, the Giants have significant challenges ahead to be recognized as serious contenders. Currently, they hold +15000 odds, the longest in the league, sharing this position with the New Orleans Saints and Tennessee Titans.

New York Giants playoff chances Special Teams of the Giants Over the Past 25 Years

Aside from Lawrence, the only other active player on this list is kicker Graham Gano, who has achieved a career AV of 15 since joining the Giants in 2020. Having been in the NFL since 2009, he has spent the last five seasons playing at the Meadowlands. With an impressive accuracy rate of 87.2% on field goals and a 95.9% success rate on extra points, Gano has proven to be an essential contributor for the Giants in recent years. No kicker has served longer than six years in that role for the Giants this century.NorthStar Bets Ontario Sportsbook , to win Super Bowl 60 in February 2026.

Punter Jeff Feagles concluded his extensive 22-year professional career with the Giants, where he set NFL records for the most career punts (1,713) and total punting yards (71,211).

Photo by USA Today, Vincent Carchietta

Jim Tomlin serves as an editor and writer with a focus on sports and gambling, bringing over 30 years of journalist expertise to the table. His articles have been featured in renowned publications such as the Tampa Bay Times, FanRag, Saturday Down South, and Saturday Tradition.

Bookmark deereplanet.com for ourOntario NFL betting guide plus much more sports coverage.

Referenced by leading media outlets including: